Impacts of agricultural intensification on avian richness at multiple scales in Dry Chaco forests

Abstract

Agricultural expansion and intensification is driving rapid landscape modification in the South American Gran Chaco, affecting biodiversity at multiple spatial scales. Research on biodiversity change in modified landscapes has focused mainly on remnant habitat patches. However, the habitat quality of the matrix is increasingly recognized as a key element for planning conservation in agricultural landscapes. We employed a multi-model selection approach to test 13 hypotheses about the influence of spatial scales and structural attributes on the richness of bird assemblages and forest specialist species within matrix types at the Argentine Dry Chaco. We selected 27 cattle ranches where six structural attributes of vegetation operating at different spatial scales (plot, edge and landscape) varied independently across a matrix intensification gradient in the agricultural frontier. We found that structural attributes operating at the plot, edge and landscape scale have significant influence on overall richness, with plot-scale attributes being more important than edge and landscape-scale attributes in driving bird occurrence in the grazing matrix. Factors operating at the plot scale had the largest influence on the richness of forest specialist species in the matrix. These results suggest that planning for the long-term conservation of Dry Chaco forests avifauna should pay attention to the effects of local agricultural management. Where further cattle production intensification cannot be avoided, implementation of highly selective clearing methods can mitigate the degradation of habitat quality for birds. Where cattle production intensification has already occurred, native tree plantings on cleared areas can restore significant bird diversity.