Assessment of Landsat-8 and Sentinel-2 Water Indices: A Case Study in the Southwest of the Buenos Aires Province (Argentina)

Abstract

The accuracy assessment of three different Normalized Difference Water indices (NDWIs) was performed in La Salada, a typical lake in the Pampean region. Data were gathered during April 2019, a period in which floods occurred in a large area in the Southwest of the Buenos Aires Province (Argentina). The accuracy of the estimations using spaceborne medium-resolution multi-spectral imaging and the reliability of three NDWIs to highlight shallow water features in satellite images were evaluated using a high-resolution airbone imagery as ground truth. We show that these indices computed using Landsat-8 and Sentinel-2 imagery are only loosely correlated to the actual flooded area in shallow waters. Indeed, NDWI values vary significantly depending on the satellite mission used and the type of index computed.