Triassic Gondwanan floral assemblages reflect paleogeography more than geologic time

Abstract

Triassic non-marine strata from Gondwana are dated almost exclusively by biostratigraphic means, given the rarity of precise radioisotopic and magnetostratigraphic datasets. A primary method for constraining the age of these sedimentary sequences is palynomorph biostratigraphy, which implicitly assumes that differences in the presence/absence of taxa between two or more assemblages reflect a difference in geological ages. But without biostratigraphically-independent age data, this assumption often remains untested. The Triassic El Peñasco Group of the Santa Clara sub-basin in the Cuyana Basin of centralwest Argentina is an excellent study system to help test these assumptions, because the upper part of the sequence comprises a fluvio-deltaic-lacustrine succession that preserves volcaniclastic horizons and extensive palynomorph assemblages. Previous palynostratigraphic analyses had inferred a Late Triassic (Carnian-Norian) age for the Santa Clara Abajo and overlying Santa Clara Arriba formations, but we present new precise U-Pb CA-TIMS zircon ages that suggest an upper Anisian (Middle Triassic) age for both formations. This makes it the only non-marine Anisian Gondwanan sequence, and one of only a handful globally, to be precisely dated geochronologically. These new ages also constrain the deposition of the >700 m-thick succession of the Santa Clara Abajo and Santa Clara Arriba formations to no more than 2.1 my of time, suggesting it represents a synrift phase of the sub-basin. Combining these and existing geochronologic data with a newly assembled comprehensive presence/absence dataset of palynomorphs from the Anisian-Norian of Gondwana, we demonstrate that paleogeography (paleolatitude) has a significantly stronger correlation with taxonomic composition of assemblages than does geologic time. These results imply that geography is an important null hypothesis in explaining differences in early Mesozoic Gondwanan palynomorph assemblages, and that precise geochronologic age constraints are important for refining the accuracy of Triassic palynomorph biochronology.