Reply to: Data do not support large-scale oligotrophication of terrestrial ecosystems

Abstract

There are many reasons that the isotopic signature of deposited N is unlikely to be causing the declines in plant δ15N. Although our analysis of foliar δ15N was limited to after 1980, declines in foliar, tree-ring and sediment δ15N pre-date the onset of widespread inorganic N fertilizer use, as well as any timing ofshifts to more reduced forms of N in deposition. Also, despite variation in the isotopic signatures of N deposition and its sources, there is no evidence currently that the signature of atmospheric N deposition has been declining overtime. A global, comprehensive dataset on the signature of N deposition does not exist and would be helpful to generate. Yet, even if the isotopic signature of N deposition has been declining, changes in N availability can have a stronger influence on plant δ15N than the signature of added N.